Art or Therapy? Two Important Facts about the Benefits of Writing

The terrain of your memories may be a minefield. As you venture in looking for past experiences to write about, you may happen upon stories that you feel you shouldn’t tell. You may find things that you don’t want to think about, details about people that you think should be kept private, or past life events fraught with pain. When, as a memoirist, you scan your memories for experiences to write about, you might hesitate. How do you navigate around recollections that might prove to be emotionally explosive? And should you?

Much has been written about the therapeutic benefits of writing. Psychologists and composition theorists tell us that we can heal through writing, that we can awaken, discover, or transform ourselves, that by writing we can improve our physical health and dissolve our emotional pain.

But as a memoirist, of course, you are not writing for the possible therapeutic benefits. You write to reach an audience of readers. You write to create literary art.  If greater physical and emotional health results from your writing, that is a fortuitous side-effect of your work.

Since they delve into the terrain of memories, with all of its potential emotional minefields, memoirists should be aware of two important facts relevant to the intersection between writing as therapy and writing memoir as an art form.   

1.  While the goals of therapeutic writing and writing memoir are different, the techniques used to achieve them are similar.

For writing to be therapeutic, the writer must do more than merely sit down and write. The process involves more than just pouring out whatever is on one’s mind. Therapeutic writing consists of locating memories of troubling experiences, then writing about them in a way that both describes them and articulates the past and present emotions associated with them.

Similarly, a memoirist in search of a subject looks to memories of experiences that come to mind, no matter how seemingly trivial, and investigates the reason that a particular experience is remembered when so many others are not. Research into the nature of memory indicates that we remember experiences that have a strong emotion associated with them. So, the memoirist, like the person who writes for therapeutic benefit, chooses to write about emotionally significant experiences, and to convey those emotions, whether directly or indirectly, to the reader.

2.  The therapeutic benefits of writing do not manifest themselves immediately.  You may feel considerably worse just after writing about an emotionally charged memory than before. The benefits may emerge weeks after the writing takes place.

My own experience with writing about difficult childhood experiences confirms this fact for me.  My intention has always been to write well about my childhood, and ultimately to turn the ugliness that is an integral part of my distant past into something beautiful. Immediately after writing, however, I have always struggled with anxiety and agitation. I have always felt worse after writing than before. I believe that I have benefited emotionally, and perhaps also physically, from having written about these painful experiences, but the benefits were not immediate. 

As a memoirist, you may experience difficulty coping with the emotional impact of the memories about which you write. You may feel so uncomfortable that you question whether you should be writing at all. I, for one, have asked that question many times. But remember that you are writing for an audience of readers who may want or need your message. You are an artist. And with time, you may reap emotional and physical benefits from your work.

So please, keep writing.     



17 responses to “Art or Therapy? Two Important Facts about the Benefits of Writing”

  1. My early years of writing were primarily therapeutic as I didn’t really have a blog audience. Because I blogged what I wrote anyway, I strove to do my best writing, but more and more frequently, I was startled by the stuff I was uncovering. It took a long time to realize I was a memoirist. I think writing can effectively be duel purpose, especially with the level of engagement on wordpress. So many people have said ‘me too’ over the years and it really helps when you’re feeling down.

    It took me years to see the benefit of my therapeutic writing. I just became more and more distressed as I discovered things about myself. Then, suddenly, it all clicked into place and I realized that the writing had actually helped me gain comfort with myself. I’m happy I never packed it in, but I seriously considered it a thousand times through that rough stretch.

    Nice thought provoking post.

    Liked by 3 people

    1. Thank you, Jeff.

      Through some of my recent writing, I think I’m finding that comfort with myself that you mention. I get discouraged with writing very easily, but lately my mantra has been, “Just keep writing. Just keep writing.” My commitment to building this blog has forced me to get at least some writing done every day.

      Liked by 3 people

      1. Tamara Kulish from https://tamarakulish.com/ Avatar
        Tamara Kulish from https://tamarakulish.com/

        The advice you’re giving to yourself to just keep writing is the best advice! That’s the way, the path, the journey!

        Like

  2. Yes on all counts! When I started blogging, it was a continuation of the diarizing I did as a kid, except knowing there might be a reader pushed me to make my writing better. But the act of reliving a memory, processing it, and trying to evoke the emotions I had associated with it was indeed therapeutic. I now sometimes find myself re-reading things and committing them to memory in my version, and if painful, it’s ok, because I’d written it out of my system, and re-digested it in a way I could manage.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Thanks for your response. Blogging has made me very aware of my reading audience, and pushed me to be a better writer, too. I’m glad you find therapeutic value in writing.

      Liked by 1 person

  3. Tamara Kulish from https://tamarakulish.com/ Avatar
    Tamara Kulish from https://tamarakulish.com/

    My writing started out trying to be therapeutic for others, to share the lessons I learned, but it ended up being very therapeutic for me too! I wrote 2 books and hundreds of posts as a result of all this therapeutic writing and plan to keep going!

    Like

    1. That’s wonderful and inspiring to hear! Wow, two books. That’s a lot of dedicated work. I admire that.

      Thanks so much for reading.

      Liked by 1 person

      1. Tamara Kulish from https://tamarakulish.com/ Avatar
        Tamara Kulish from https://tamarakulish.com/

        My pleasure! Keep going!

        Liked by 1 person

  4. Tamara Kulish from https://tamarakulish.com/ Avatar
    Tamara Kulish from https://tamarakulish.com/

    The advice you’re giving to yourself to just keep writing is the best advice! That’s the way, the path, the journey!

    Liked by 1 person

  5. What a great piece to tease out the similarities and differences. I love, “Similarly, a memoirist in search of a subject looks to memories of experiences that come to mind, no matter how seemingly trivial, and investigates the reason that a particular experience is remembered when so many others are not. ” Wow!

    Thanks for the encouragement to keep writing, Georgia!

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Thank you for your thoughtful response, Wynne. I’m glad my post was meaningful to you.

      Liked by 1 person

  6. Hi, Georgia! So nice to meet you. I loved this post…and have Wynne Leon to thank for sharing your blog with me. You wisdom about writing about the deep experiences and the nuances of therapeutic writing…especially the time it takes, the “readiness”, was lovely to read. I agree! Thank you for your post! 😉

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Hello, Victoria. Happy to meet you! Thank you for reading and responding. I’m glad you found my post useful.

      Liked by 1 person

  7. I’ve lost track of how many letters written–both to myself and others–and never sent.

    Like

  8. You get the therapeutic benefit of writing your feelings without sending the letter and possibly hurting someone or jeopardizing a relationship. That’s very smart!

    Thank you for reading and responding.

    Like

Leave a comment